As the weather finally turns in Pittsburgh, so does the collective mood: suddenly, everyone is outside, everyone is walking somewhere, and everyone is thinking about ice cream. Fortunately, this is a town that takes frozen desserts seriously. So, in the spirit of extremely unofficial journalism, we set out to visit a handful of local favorites and compare the goods. From classic soft serve to elevated hand-churned scoops, these are a few of the very best in Pittsburgh — and yes, we picked a winner.
Pitting Pittsburgh’s Best Ice Cream Parlors Against One Another
Leona’s Ice Cream
There’s always something new to try at Leona’s Ice Cream in Garfield — and that’s part of the fun. What began as a beloved cookie-and-ice-cream-sandwich business has grown beautifully into a brick-and-mortar scoop shop where creativity is clearly the point. Alongside staples like Chocolate and Black Sesame, there are more playful, elegant flavors that feel distinctly Leona’s. The Lavender & Honeycomb is a standout; it’s creamy, fragrant and floral (without veering into candle territory). Swirls of honey and crunchy bites of honeycomb give it texture and depth. It feels thoughtful and balanced — and just a little bit luxurious.
Dave & Andy’s Homemade Ice Cream
I love Dave & Andy’s in Oakland — and I love it even more after my latest visit. Part of the thrill is never knowing exactly what will be in the case at the Oakland shop; with more than 200 flavors in its rotation (including Red Velvet, Creme Brulee, German Chocolate and Fig Newton), Dave & Andy’s has long embraced a more-is-more philosophy. I went for a four-pack sampler, one of the best ordering options in the city, and tried Chocolate, Lavender, Cookies and Cream and Sweet Cream Vanilla (a slightly less-sweet, deeply satisfying take on the classic). I sampled even more flavors beyond that quartet — and every bite delivered.
Happy Day Dessert Factory
At Happy Day Dessert Factory on the North Side, ice cream is only part of the story — but it’s a very good part. The menu is sprawling in the best way, with water ices, hand-dipped cones and homemade flavors including Samosas Cookies, Banana Cream Pie and Golden Vanilla. Still, it was the custard that won me over completely. A small, chocolate-and-vanilla twist had that ideal texture you look for in a custard. It was impossibly smooth, almost whipped, with the kind of richness that somehow still feels light. It’s the sort of treat you finish quickly — before you’re struck with regret at not ordering a larger size. Add a freshly baked waffle cone or one of their cookies and you’re set.
Millie’s
At this point, Millie’s is well on its way to becoming a true Pittsburgh institution. With multiple locations and a deeply loyal following, Chad and Lauren Townsend’s scoop shop (which first debuted in 2014) has built a reputation on homemade ice cream that feels both inventive and dependable. Yes, there are beloved flavors — Nutty Pistachio, Black Raspberry Chip and Strawberry Matcha — and they’re worth the hype. But the real surprise is how well Millie’s handles the basics. Chocolate and Chad’s Vanilla (developed, we’re told, after extensive testing) are excellent reminders that classic flavors are only boring when done badly. Here, they’re subtle, pure and exactly what chocolate and vanilla should taste like.
Page’s Dairy Mart
Pittsburgh spring does not truly begin until Page’s opens for the season. Now celebrating its 70th year, the South Side standby remains one of the city’s most beloved warm-weather rituals, and the long lines curling around the block are proof that no one minds the wait. The menu is extensive, with more than two dozen specialty soft-serve flavors (from Birthday Cake and Coffee to Peanut Butter and Toasted Coconut) plus sundaes and all the expected extras. But honestly, Page’s doesn’t need to overcomplicate things. A simple vanilla with sprinkles is enough to remind you why this place has endured. The soft serve is delicious, the vanilla is near-perfect and the atmosphere seals it.
And the Winner Is …
There wasn’t a bad bite in the bunch. Each of these shops offers something worth going out of your way for, whether it’s Page’s nostalgic soft serve, Millie’s polished classics, Leona’s inventive elegance or Happy Day’s dreamy custard. But if we’re crowning just one winner in this very unofficial Ice Cream Wars, it has to be Dave & Andy’s. Even with a change in ownership in recent years, the shop hasn’t lost what made it special in the first place. The flavors are playful, the texture is spot-on and the ice cream still tastes deeply homemade in the best possible way. In a city full of excellent scoops, Dave & Andy’s still comes out on top … at least until the next chapter of Ice Cream Wars.
Story by Emily Catalano
Featured Photo From Millie’s
Other Photos by Emily Catalano
Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.
