Two fall favorites come together in our Pumpkin Pancakes recipe for a dish full of cozy, autumn flavor. Who can resist pumpkins and apples when the leaves turn brown and orange? These warm, fluffy pancakes are like a pumpkin spice latte in breakfast form. This recipe gets an added flare when topped with a homemade apple compote. Easy to make, even easier to eat.
What is Apple Compote?
Apple compote is a delicious and versatile dessert that is made from cooked apples. It’s almost like a syrup with fresh apple chunks inside. It can be served warm or cold and is often spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, or cloves. Compote is a great way to use up apples that are past their prime, and can be used as a topping for ice cream or yogurt, filling for pies and tart, or, in this case, added on top of pancakes!
Pumpkin Pancakes
-
Yield:
Serves 4
Description
A breakfast full of fall flavors.
Ingredients
Scale
For the Pancakes:
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 2 tsp baking powder
- 1 tsp kosher salt
- 2 tbsp sugar
- ¼ cup pumpkin puree
- 2 large eggs
- 2 ¾ cups buttermilk
- 1 tbsp blended oil
For the Apple Compote:
- 1 Granny Smith apple, peeled, cored, and medium-diced
- 3 tbsp sugar
- 3 tbsp water or apple cider
- 1 cinnamon stick
Instructions
For the Pancakes:
- In a bowl, combine first five dry ingredients and mix well.
- In another bowl, combine puree, eggs, buttermilk and oil; mix well.
- Combine wet into dry and then fold together. Do not over mix. Let rest 5 minutes.
For the Apple Compote:
- Combine all ingredients and simmer until syrup forms. Remove cinnamon and keep warm.
window.trCommon={“minRating”:6,”ajaxurl”:”https://www.tablemagazine.com/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php”,”ratingNonce”:”2003796080″,”postId”:3432};
window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {};
window.TastyRecipes.smoothScroll = {
init() {
document.addEventListener( ‘click’, ( e ) => {
let anchor = e.target;
if ( anchor.tagName !== ‘A’ ) {
anchor = anchor.closest( ‘a.tasty-recipes-scrollto’ );
}
if ( ! anchor || ! anchor.classList.contains( ‘tasty-recipes-scrollto’ ) ) {
return;
}
const elementHref = anchor.getAttribute( ‘href’ );
if ( ! elementHref ) {
return;
}
e.preventDefault();
this.goToSelector( elementHref );
});
},
goToSelector( selector ) {
const element = document.querySelector( selector );
if ( ! element ) {
return;
}
element.scrollIntoView( { behavior: ‘smooth’ } );
}
};
document.addEventListener(
‘DOMContentLoaded’,
() => window.TastyRecipes.smoothScroll.init()
);
(function(){
var bothEquals = function( d1, d2, D ) {
var ret = 0;
if (d1<=D) {
ret++;
}
if (d2<=D) {
ret++;
}
return ret === 2;
};
var frac =function frac(x,D,mixed){var n1=Math.floor(x),d1=1;var n2=n1+1,d2=1;if(x!==n1)while(bothEquals(d1,d2,D)){var m=(n1+n2)/(d1+d2);if(x===m){if(d1+d2d2)d2=D+1;else d1=D+1;break}else if(xD){d1=d2;n1=n2}if(!mixed)return[0,n1,d1];var q=Math.floor(n1/d1);return[q,n1-q*d1,d1]};frac.cont=function cont(x,D,mixed){var sgn=x<0?-1:1;var B=x*sgn;var P_2=0,P_1=1,P=0;var Q_2=1,Q_1=0,Q=0;var A=Math.floor(B);while(Q_1<D){A=Math.floor(B);P=A*P_1+P_2;Q=A*Q_1+Q_2;if(B-AD){if(Q_1>D){Q=Q_2;P=P_2}else{Q=Q_1;P=P_1}}if(!mixed)return[0,sgn*P,Q];var q=Math.floor(sgn*P/Q);return[q,sgn*P-q*Q,Q]};
window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions = JSON.parse(decodeURIComponent(“%7B%22%C2%BC%22%3A%221%2F4%22%2C%22%C2%BD%22%3A%221%2F2%22%2C%22%C2%BE%22%3A%223%2F4%22%2C%22%E2%85%93%22%3A%221%2F3%22%2C%22%E2%85%94%22%3A%222%2F3%22%2C%22%E2%85%95%22%3A%221%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%96%22%3A%222%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%97%22%3A%223%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%98%22%3A%224%2F5%22%2C%22%E2%85%99%22%3A%221%2F6%22%2C%22%E2%85%9A%22%3A%225%2F6%22%2C%22%E2%85%9B%22%3A%221%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9C%22%3A%223%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9D%22%3A%225%2F8%22%2C%22%E2%85%9E%22%3A%227%2F8%22%7D”));
window.tastyRecipesFormatAmount = function(amount, el) {
if ( parseFloat( amount ) === parseInt( amount ) ) {
return amount;
}
var roundType = ‘frac’;
if (typeof el.dataset.amountShouldRound !== ‘undefined’) {
if (‘false’ !== el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
if ( ‘number’ === el.dataset.amountShouldRound ) {
roundType = ‘number’;
} else if (‘frac’ === el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
roundType = ‘frac’;
} else if (‘vulgar’ === el.dataset.amountShouldRound) {
roundType = ‘vulgar’;
} else {
roundType = ‘integer’;
}
}
}
if (‘number’ === roundType) {
amount = Number.parseFloat(amount).toPrecision(2);
} else if (‘integer’ === roundType) {
amount = Math.round(amount);
} else if (‘frac’ === roundType || ‘vulgar’ === roundType) {
var denom = 8;
if (typeof el.dataset.unit !== ‘undefined’) {
var unit = el.dataset.unit;
if ([‘cups’,’cup’,’c’].includes(unit)) {
denom = 4;
if (0.125 === amount) {
denom = 8;
}
if (“0.1667″ === Number.parseFloat( amount ).toPrecision(4)) {
denom = 6;
}
}
if ([‘tablespoons’,’tablespoon’,’tbsp’].includes(unit)) {
denom = 2;
}
if ([‘teaspoons’,’teaspoon’,’tsp’].includes(unit)) {
denom = 8;
}
}
var amountArray = frac.cont( amount, denom, true );
var newAmount = ”;
if ( amountArray[1] !== 0 ) {
newAmount = amountArray[1] + ‘/’ + amountArray[2];
if (‘vulgar’ === roundType) {
Object.keys(window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions).forEach(function(vulgar) {
if (newAmount === window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions[vulgar]) {
newAmount = vulgar;
}
});
}
}
if ( newAmount ) {
newAmount = ‘ ‘ + newAmount;
}
if ( amountArray[0] ) {
newAmount = amountArray[0] + newAmount;
}
amount = newAmount;
}
return amount;
};
window.tastyRecipesUpdatePrintLink = () => {
const printButton = document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-print-button’ );
if ( ! printButton ) {
return;
}
const printURL = new URL( printButton.href );
const searchParams = new URLSearchParams( printURL.search );
const unitButton = document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-convert-button-active’ );
const scaleButton = document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-scale-button-active’ );
let unit = ”;
let scale = ”;
if ( unitButton ) {
unit = unitButton.dataset.unitType;
searchParams.delete(‘unit’);
searchParams.set( ‘unit’, unit );
}
if ( scaleButton ) {
scale = scaleButton.dataset.amount;
searchParams.set( ‘scale’, scale );
}
const paramString = searchParams.toString();
const newURL = ” === paramString ? printURL.href : printURL.origin + printURL.pathname + ‘?’ + paramString;
const printLinks = document.querySelectorAll( ‘.tasty-recipes-print-link’ );
printLinks.forEach( ( el ) => {
el.href = newURL;
});
const printButtons = document.querySelectorAll( ‘.tasty-recipes-print-button’ );
printButtons.forEach( ( el ) => {
el.href = newURL;
});
};
document.addEventListener( ‘DOMContentLoaded’, () => {
if ( ! window.location.href.includes( ‘/print/’ ) ) {
return;
}
const searchParams = new URLSearchParams( window.location.search );
const unit = searchParams.get( ‘unit’ );
const scale = searchParams.get( ‘scale’ );
if ( unit && ( ‘metric’ === unit || ‘usc’ === unit ) ) {
document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-convert-button[data-unit-type=”‘ + unit + ‘”]’ ).click();
}
if ( scale && Number(scale) > 0 ) {
document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-scale-button[data-amount=”‘ + Number(scale) + ‘”]’ ).click();
}
});
}());
(function(){
var buttonClass = ‘tasty-recipes-scale-button’,
buttonActiveClass = ‘tasty-recipes-scale-button-active’,
buttons = document.querySelectorAll(‘.tasty-recipes-scale-button’);
if ( ! buttons ) {
return;
}
buttons.forEach(function(button){
button.addEventListener(‘click’, function(event){
event.preventDefault();
var recipe = event.target.closest(‘.tasty-recipes’);
if ( ! recipe ) {
return;
}
var otherButtons = recipe.querySelectorAll(‘.’ + buttonClass);
otherButtons.forEach(function(bt){
bt.classList.remove(buttonActiveClass);
});
button.classList.add(buttonActiveClass);
var scalables = recipe.querySelectorAll(‘span[data-amount]’);
var buttonAmount = parseFloat( button.dataset.amount );
scalables.forEach(function(scalable){
if (typeof scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType === ‘undefined’
&& typeof scalable.dataset.nfOriginal === ‘undefined’) {
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf(‘/’)) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = ‘frac’;
}
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf(‘.’)) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = ‘number’;
}
Object.keys(window.tastyRecipesVulgarFractions).forEach(function(vulgar) {
if (-1 !== scalable.innerText.indexOf(vulgar)) {
scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType = ‘vulgar’;
}
});
if (typeof scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType !== ‘undefined’) {
scalable.dataset.amountShouldRound = scalable.dataset.amountOriginalType;
}
}
var amount = parseFloat( scalable.dataset.amount ) * buttonAmount;
amount = window.tastyRecipesFormatAmount(amount, scalable);
if ( typeof scalable.dataset.unit !== ‘undefined’ ) {
if ( ! scalable.classList.contains(‘nutrifox-quantity’) ) {
if ( ! scalable.classList.contains(‘nutrifox-second-quantity’) ) {
amount += ‘ ‘ + scalable.dataset.unit;
}
}
}
scalable.innerText = amount;
});
var nonNumerics = recipe.querySelectorAll(‘[data-has-non-numeric-amount]’);
nonNumerics.forEach(function(nonNumeric){
var indicator = nonNumeric.querySelector(‘span[data-non-numeric-label]’);
if ( indicator ) {
nonNumeric.removeChild(indicator);
}
if ( 1 !== buttonAmount ) {
indicator = document.createElement(‘span’);
indicator.setAttribute(‘data-non-numeric-label’, true);
var text = document.createTextNode(‘ (x’ + buttonAmount + ‘)’);
indicator.appendChild(text);
nonNumeric.appendChild(indicator);
}
});
window.tastyRecipesUpdatePrintLink();
});
});
}());
window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {};
window.TastyRecipes.cookMode = {
wakeLockApi: false,
wakeLock: false,
cookModeSelector: ‘.tasty-recipes-cook-mode’,
init() {
if (“wakeLock” in navigator && “request” in navigator.wakeLock) {
this.wakeLockApi = navigator.wakeLock;
}
const cookModes = document.querySelectorAll(this.cookModeSelector);
if (cookModes.length > 0) {
for (const cookMode of cookModes) {
if (this.wakeLockApi) {
cookMode.querySelector(‘input[type=”checkbox”]’).addEventListener(“change”, event => {
this.checkboxChange(event.target);
}, false);
} else {
cookMode.style.display = “none”;
}
}
}
},
checkboxChange(checkbox) {
if (checkbox.checked) {
this.lock();
} else {
this.unlock();
}
},
setCheckboxesState(state) {
const checkboxes = document.querySelectorAll(this.cookModeSelector + ‘ input[type=”checkbox”]’);
for (const checkbox of checkboxes) {
checkbox.checked = state;
}
},
async lock() {
try {
this.wakeLock = await this.wakeLockApi.request(“screen”);
this.wakeLock.addEventListener(“release”, () => {
this.wakeLock = false;
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
});
this.setCheckboxesState(true);
} catch (error) {
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
}
},
unlock() {
if (this.wakeLock) {
this.wakeLock.release();
this.wakeLock = false;
}
this.setCheckboxesState(false);
}
};
(function(callback) {
if (document.readyState !== “loading”) {
callback();
} else {
document.addEventListener(“DOMContentLoaded”, callback);
}
})(() => {
window.TastyRecipes.cookMode.init();
});
window.TastyRecipes = window.TastyRecipes || {};
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip = {
element: null,
tooltipElement: null,
deleting: false,
init( element ) {
if ( this.deleting ) {
return;
}
this.element = element;
this.buildElements();
},
destroy() {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement || this.deleting ) {
return;
}
this.deleting = true;
this.tooltipElement.classList.remove( ‘opened’ );
setTimeout( () => {
this.tooltipElement.remove();
this.deleting = false;
}, 500 );
},
buildElements() {
const tooltipElement = document.createElement( ‘div’ );
tooltipElement.classList.add( ‘tasty-recipes-static-tooltip’);
tooltipElement.setAttribute( ‘id’, ‘tasty-recipes-tooltip’ );
const currentTooltipElement = document.getElementById( ‘tasty-recipes-tooltip’ );
if ( currentTooltipElement ) {
document.body.replaceChild( tooltipElement, currentTooltipElement );
} else {
document.body.appendChild( tooltipElement );
}
this.tooltipElement = document.getElementById( ‘tasty-recipes-tooltip’ );
},
show() {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement ) {
return;
}
const tooltipTop = this.element.getBoundingClientRect().top
+ window.scrollY
– 10 // 10px offset.
– this.tooltipElement.getBoundingClientRect().height;
const tooltipLeft = this.element.getBoundingClientRect().left
– ( this.tooltipElement.getBoundingClientRect().width / 2 )
+ ( this.element.getBoundingClientRect().width / 2 ) – 1;
const posLeft = Math.max( 10, tooltipLeft );
this.maybeRemoveTail( posLeft !== tooltipLeft );
this.tooltipElement.setAttribute( ‘style’, ‘top:’ + tooltipTop + ‘px;left:’ + posLeft + ‘px;’ );
this.tooltipElement.classList.add( ‘opened’ );
},
maybeRemoveTail( removeTail ) {
if ( removeTail ) {
this.tooltipElement.classList.add( ‘tr-hide-tail’ );
} else {
this.tooltipElement.classList.remove( ‘tr-hide-tail’ );
}
},
changeMessage( message ) {
if ( ! this.tooltipElement ) {
return;
}
this.tooltipElement.innerHTML = message;
}
};
window.TastyRecipes.ajax = {
sendPostRequest( url, data, success, failure ) {
const xhr = new XMLHttpRequest();
xhr.open( ‘POST’, url, true );
xhr.send( this.preparePostData( data ) );
xhr.onreadystatechange = () => {
if ( 4 !== xhr.readyState ) {
return;
}
if ( xhr.status === 200 ) {
success( JSON.parse( xhr.responseText ) );
return;
}
failure( xhr );
};
xhr.onerror = () => {
failure( xhr );
};
},
preparePostData( data ) {
const formData = new FormData();
for ( const key in data ) {
formData.append( key, data[key] );
}
return formData;
},
};
window.TastyRecipes.ratings = {
defaultRating: 0,
currentRatingPercentage: 100,
savingRating: false,
init( minRating ) {
this.minRating = minRating;
this.formWatchRating();
this.closeTooltipWhenClickOutside();
this.addBodyClassBasedOnSelectedRating();
this.backwardCompFormRatingPosition();
},
formWatchRating() {
const ratings = document.querySelectorAll(‘.tasty-recipes-no-ratings-buttons [data-rating]’);
if ( ratings.length {
event.preventDefault();
this.defaultRating = event.target.closest( ‘.checked’ ).dataset.rating;
this.setCheckedStar( event.target );
this.maybeSendRating( this.defaultRating, event.target );
this.setRatingInForm( this.defaultRating );
} );
}
},
closeTooltipWhenClickOutside() {
window.addEventListener( ‘click’, e => {
// Bailout (don’t remove the tooltip) when the clicked element is a rating star, or it’s the tooltip itself.
if ( e.target.closest( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating’ ) || e.target.classList.contains( ‘tasty-recipes-static-tooltip’ ) ) {
return;
}
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.destroy();
} );
},
setRatingInForm( rating ) {
const ratingInput = document.querySelector( ‘#respond .tasty-recipes-rating[value=”‘ + rating + ‘”]’ );
if ( ! ratingInput ) {
return;
}
ratingInput.click();
},
addBodyClassBasedOnSelectedRating() {
const ratingInputs = document.querySelectorAll( ‘input.tasty-recipes-rating’ );
if ( ! ratingInputs ) {
return;
}
for ( const ratingInput of ratingInputs ) {
ratingInput.addEventListener( ‘click’, currentEvent => {
const selectedRating = currentEvent.target.getAttribute( ‘value’ );
this.handleBodyClassByRating( selectedRating );
this.toggleCommentTextareaRequired( selectedRating );
} );
}
},
handleBodyClassByRating( rating ) {
if ( rating < this.minRating ) {
document.body.classList.remove( 'tasty-recipes-selected-minimum-rating' );
return;
}
document.body.classList.add( 'tasty-recipes-selected-minimum-rating' );
},
toggleCommentTextareaRequired( rating ) {
const commentTextarea = document.getElementById( 'comment' );
if ( ! commentTextarea ) {
return;
}
if ( rating {
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.changeMessage( response.data.message );
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.show();
this.updateAverageText( response.data, recipeCardElement );
this.maybeFillCommentForm( response.data );
// Hide the tooltip after 5 seconds.
setTimeout( () => {
this.maybeResetTooltip( recipeCardElement, response.data, rating );
}, 5000 );
},
() => {
this.resetTooltip( recipeCardElement );
}
);
},
updateAverageText( data, recipeCardElement ) {
if ( ! data.average ) {
return;
}
this.setRatingPercent( data );
if ( ! data.count ) {
return;
}
const quickLink = document.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating-link’ );
if ( quickLink ) {
this.setTextInContainer( quickLink, data );
this.setPartialStar( quickLink );
}
const cardStars = recipeCardElement.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons’ );
cardStars.dataset.trDefaultRating = data.average;
this.setTextInContainer( recipeCardElement.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating’ ), data );
},
setTextInContainer( container, data ) {
if ( ! container ) {
return;
}
if ( data.label ) {
const ratingLabelElement = container.querySelector( ‘.rating-label’ );
if ( ratingLabelElement ) {
ratingLabelElement.innerHTML = data.label;
}
return;
}
const averageElement = container.querySelector( ‘.average’ );
if ( averageElement ) {
averageElement.textContent = data.average;
}
const countElement = container.querySelector( ‘.count’ );
if ( countElement ) {
countElement.textContent = data.count;
}
},
setPartialStar( container ) {
const highestStar = container.querySelector( ‘[data-rating=”‘ + Math.ceil( this.defaultRating ) + ‘”]’ );
if ( highestStar ) {
highestStar.dataset.trClip = this.currentRatingPercentage;
}
},
setRatingPercent( data ) {
this.defaultRating = data.average.toFixed( 1 );
const parts = data.average.toFixed( 2 ).toString().split( ‘.’ );
this.currentRatingPercentage = parts[1] ? parts[1] : 100;
if ( this.currentRatingPercentage === ’00’ ) {
this.currentRatingPercentage = 100;
}
},
setCheckedStar( target ) {
const cardRatingContainer = target.closest( ‘.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons’ );
const selectedRatingElement = cardRatingContainer.querySelector( ‘[data-tr-checked]’ );
if ( selectedRatingElement ) {
delete selectedRatingElement.dataset.trChecked;
}
const thisStar = target.closest( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating’ );
thisStar.dataset.trChecked = 1;
thisStar.querySelector( ‘[data-tr-clip]’ ).dataset.trClip = 100;
},
maybeFillCommentForm( data ) {
if ( ! data.comment || ! data.comment.content ) {
return;
}
const commentForm = document.querySelector( ‘#commentform’ );
if ( ! commentForm ) {
return;
}
const commentBox = commentForm.querySelector( ‘[name=comment]’ );
if ( ! commentBox || commentBox.value ) {
return;
}
// Add comment details for editing.
commentBox.innerHTML = data.comment.content;
if ( data.comment.name ) {
commentForm.querySelector( ‘[name=author]’ ).value = data.comment.name;
commentForm.querySelector( ‘[name=email]’ ).value = data.comment.email;
}
},
maybeResetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data, rating ) {
if ( this.savingRating === rating ) {
this.resetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data );
}
},
resetTooltip( recipeCardElement, data ) {
window.TastyRecipes.staticTooltip.destroy();
this.savingRating = false;
// Reset the default rating.
const cardRatingContainer = recipeCardElement.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons’ );
if ( cardRatingContainer ) {
this.defaultRating = ( data && data.average ) ? data.average.toFixed(1) : cardRatingContainer.dataset.trDefaultRating;
cardRatingContainer.dataset.trDefaultRating = this.defaultRating;
this.resetSelectedStar( cardRatingContainer, data );
}
},
resetSelectedStar( cardRatingContainer ) {
const selectedRatingElement = cardRatingContainer.querySelector( ‘[data-rating=”‘ + Math.ceil( this.defaultRating ) + ‘”]’ );
if ( selectedRatingElement ) {
selectedRatingElement.querySelector( ‘[data-tr-clip]’ ).dataset.trClip = this.currentRatingPercentage;
selectedRatingElement.parentNode.dataset.trChecked = 1;
}
const previousSelectedElement= cardRatingContainer.querySelector( ‘[data-tr-checked]’ );
if ( previousSelectedElement ) {
const currentSelectedRating = previousSelectedElement.querySelector(‘[data-rating]’);
if ( currentSelectedRating !== selectedRatingElement ) {
delete previousSelectedElement.dataset.trChecked;
}
}
},
backwardCompFormRatingPosition() {
const ratingsButtons = document.querySelector( ‘#respond .tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons, #tasty-recipes-comment-rating .tasty-recipes-ratings-buttons’ );
if ( ! ratingsButtons ) {
return;
}
const ratingsButtonsStyles = window.getComputedStyle(ratingsButtons);
if ( ! ratingsButtonsStyles.display.includes( ‘flex’ ) ) {
ratingsButtons.style.direction = ‘rtl’;
}
if ( typeof tastyRecipesRating !== ‘undefined’ ) {
// Select the rating that was previously selected in admin.
ratingsButtons.querySelector( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating[value=”‘ + tastyRecipesRating + ‘”]’ ).checked = true;
}
const ratingSpans = ratingsButtons.querySelectorAll( ‘.tasty-recipes-rating’ );
for (const ratingSpan of ratingSpans) {
ratingSpan.addEventListener( ‘click’, event => {
if ( ratingSpan === event.target ) {
return;
}
ratingSpan.previousElementSibling.click();
} );
}
}
};
(function(callback) {
if (document.readyState !== “loading”) {
callback();
} else {
window.addEventListener( ‘load’, callback );
}
})(() => {
window.TastyRecipes.ratings.init( window.trCommon ? window.trCommon.minRating : 4 );
});
Recipe by David Haick / Photography by Laura Petrilla / Styling by Keith Recker