Pumpkin Spice Mai Tai

“Everyone loves a Mai Tai,” says Pittsburgh bartender Kaitlin Fellers, “And this pumpkin-spiced variation should be no exception.” Using Maggie’s Farm Rum spiced and 50/50 dark rums, Kaitlin creates the perfect combination of orange, clove, and molasses in this Tiki drink-turned-fall. A touch of orgeat, the creamy, mildly sweet nonalcoholic syrup that stars many classic Tiki-inspired cocktails, adds an extra dash of flavor. “You’ll want to keep sipping,” Kaitlin assures.

Pumpkin Spice Mai Tai Cocktail Recipe


1 oz Maggie’s Farm 50/50 Dark Rum
1 oz Maggie’s Farm Spiced Rum
¾ oz Grand Marnier
¾ oz spiced pumpkin seed orgeat
¾ oz lime juice
1 heaping tsp pumpkin puree
2 dashes Angostura bitters


For the orgeat: Combine 1.5 cups toasted, unsalted pumpkin seeds with 2.75 cups almost boiling water, 1 tsp ground cinnamon, and 1 tsp salt. Blend on high for about 1 minute or until smooth, then strain the mixture through a fine-mesh strainer or cheesecloth. While your pumpkin seed “milk” is still hot, weigh your mixture on a baking scale and add an equal amount of granulated white sugar by weight. Stir to completely dissolve sugar.

For the cocktail: Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker and shake to combine, for about 20-30 seconds. Strain with a cocktail strainer and fine mesh strainer into a double rocks glass filled with ice. Garnish with a lime wheel and freshly grated nutmeg.

Recipe by Kaitlin Fellers / Photography by Dave Bryce

A footer photo with a grey and white marble background, three TABLE Magazines and subscribe info and button

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.


We respect your privacy.


Related Articles

Hanukkah 75 Cocktail

Celebrate in style.

Ginger Snap Cocktail

A brew that warms you with its temperature and spices.

Hot, Hot, Hot, Hot Chocolate

A spiked hot chocolate to drink while watching The Polar Express.