The holidays are upon us, and the pressure is on to find the perfect stocking stuffers for your loved ones before time runs out. Fear not, fellow gift-givers! Pittsburgh is a treasure trove of unique shops brimming with quirky finds and locally-made treasures. From eccentric gift shops to charming bookstores, this city is a haven for stocking stuffer inspiration. So ditch the department store monotony and get ready to discover some truly special and memorable gifts that will make this holiday season extra festive.

Where to Buy the Perfect Stocking Stuffers in Pittsburgh

Kards Unlimited

There’s something to be said about Kards Unlimited. This store truly has just about everything you could imagine for gift giving and so much more. Shop through aisles of books, stationary materials, shirts, mugs, tote bags, desk accessories, and bumper stickers. Plus, their selection of greeting cards spans from classic designs to unique sayings and jokes. 

Songbird Artistry

Handmade jewelry, soaps, and custom apparel line the walls of Songbird Artistry. You may recognize this shop from their stall at the People’s Gas Holiday Market in Market Square. Not only will you find Pittsburgh themed earrings and soap but you’ll also browse pop culture reference pieces like Disney characters and other figures. 

Love, Pittsburgh

If your family has a soft spot for Pittsburgh, this is the ultimate place for all things pierogies, Steelers, and so much more. Whether you’re looking for a candle that smells like the city’s famous cookie tables or a bookmark with the city’s skyline, they have everything to make your little yinzer heart beat with joy. 

Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop

Is grandma always talking about an old school candy she can no longer find? Head out to Grandpa Joe’s Candy Shop to find retro candies you forgot about and exclusive types from other countries. They also carry a number of little gifts you won’t find elsewhere like Mr. Rogers Encourage-Mints or a gag gift that’ll have the whole room laughing. 

Caliban Book Shop

Nothing says care and thoughtfulness like picking out a book from a bookstore. Carefully selecting the perfect work for someone takes an extreme amount of reflection. The best part about Caliban Book Shop is that they carry both used books and new books on their Karen’s Book Row. This way you’re sure to find the best book to stuff their stocking with. 

Wildcard

This gift shop has a little something for even the hardest person to gift on your list. Their capacity for stocking stuffers houses fun sock designs, cute tote bags, Pittsburgh keychains, and so much more. Plus, if you need to pick up one or two more big gifts on your list, they have shirts and other accessories for everyday life. 

Mon Aimee Chocolat

Who doesn’t love to open their stocking to find a box of chocolates sitting on top? Mon Aimee Chocolat specializes in handcrafted chocolates, some of which even come from other countries. These exquisite pieces come in classics like milk and dark or other varieties like almond bark, malt balls, and bon bons. 

Pennsylvania Macaroni Company 

For the culinary lover in your life, Pennsylvania Macaroni Company carries imported and specialty foods and beverages that anyone would love to receive. Pick them up a special jar of olives for their stocking or maybe even a block of fresh cheese with a cheese knife to accompany it. 

Museum Gift Shops

Another great place to pick up stocking stuffers is at the museum stores stationed throughout the city. Check out our article on must-shop museum stores to find something for the artsy, unique person in your life. 

Story by Kylie Thomas
Photo Courtesy of Annie Spratt

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.