It’s hard to shop for a cat lover in your life: they already have a cat-shaped mug, multiple pairs of cat-patterned socks, and plenty of toys their furry friend ditches when a new cardboard box enters the home. Shopping locally for cat lovers can be just as challenging. However, it’s not impossible, and your gift makes an even bigger impact when it comes from a neighborhood business.
What Are the Best Local Gift Shops for Pittsburgh Cat Lovers?
Lawrenceville Pet Supply
Lawrenceville Pet Supply on Butler Street has been in business for a decade, and it harvests and dries its own catnip every year. You’ll also find cat toys, treats, and customer service not found at a big box pet store.
What to gift: A block of cat grass for their home or a bag of the house catnip, if it’s not sold out. The cat grass adds some greenery for the human, and it’s a plant that won’t upset a cat’s stomach when they inevitably snack on it. In fact, cat grass aids digestion.
The Black Cat Market
The Black Cat Market in Garfield is a cat cafe and rescue hub. Its shop sells cat-related goods, including toys and cat wine. More than 1,000 cats have been adopted from the shop since 2019.
What to gift: A session in the cat room with adoptable cats with a Black Cat Market T-shirt from the shop. Check its calendar for yoga or art nights for even more feline fun.
Cats N’At
Cats N’At in Wexford has a boutique with cat-themed collectables from local businesses, separate from its cat lounge, and every visit helps its rescue partner.
What to gift: A kitty-themed collectible or handmade craft from the boutique, plus a bag of prepackaged snacks for cats and their people.
Cattfeinated Cat Cafe
This Greensburg cat cafe has two cat rooms, a full coffee bar, an on-site thrift shop, and pet-themed merch. It has placed more than 700 cats into loving homes since it opened in 2019.
What to gift: A 45-minute cat room visit and a coffee, finished off with a piece of the cafe’s merch.
Petagogy
Petagogy’s shops in East Liberty, McCandless, McMurray, Cranberry and Greensburg carry freeze-dried and raw options for cats, perfect for someone who wants to make sure their cat is eating high-quality ingredients.
What to gift: A bag of freeze-dried cat treats or a Go Cat wand toy with interchangeable attachments picky-eater-approved upgrade from .
Yinzer Dog
Don’t let the name fool you: Yinzer Dog is a Pittsburgh-themed line of dog and cat toys from Toni Shelaske, who started it after nearly 20 years running the local natural pet store Healthy Pet Products.
What to gift: Although we’d snag every available cat toy if possible, we’re quite fond of the ketchup bottle.
The Gift That Gives Back
One of the best gifts you can give to a cat lover in your life is a donation to one of Pittsburgh’s many local rescues. Make a donation in the name of a pet who has crossed the rainbow bridge, or give back to the shelter where your friend found their soul pet. It’s a meaningful gesture that supports animal rescue work in Pittsburgh and beyond.
Check out our picks of the best local shops for Pittsburgh dog lovers.
Read more about shopping local for the holidays in Pittsburgh.
About the Author
Amanda Reed has written for Popular Science, Pittsburgh Magazine, Pittsburgh City Paper, Very Local Pittsburgh, GearPatrol and TheStreet. Amanda earned the 2021 Ray Sprigle Best of Show Award from the Western Pennsylvania Press Club for a story on stressed-out college counseling centers. She lives in Bloomfield with JunkJunk, a handsome, sad-looking tuxedo cat who wants only wet food and attention.
Photo by Kevin Turcios
Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition




