11 Holiday Pie Recipes, from Apple and Pecan to Chocolate Mint

Some people come to the holiday table for turkey. The rest of us are quietly saving room for pie. Few desserts have as many personalities. It can be flaky or crumbly, fruity or creamy, cozy and spiced, or rich enough to share with the whole table.

- Advertisement -

Below, you’ll find 11 of our favorite pie recipes from TABLE’s contributors, chefs, and local farmers. They cover classic apple, sweet potato, and pecan pies, four berry and stone-fruit pies, and three cream and chocolate pies that need little or no time in the oven. Consider them your starting point for becoming your family’s resident pastry expert.

Which Holiday Pie Recipes Should You Bake First?

Best for Thanksgiving: Apple Pie, Sweet Potato Pie, and Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie.

- Advertisement -

Best for Christmas: White Christmas Coconut Pie and Chocolate Mint Pie.

Best no-bake filling: The Richest Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie and Raspberry Glaze Pie.

- Advertisement -

Best gluten-free: Whole Grain, Gluten-Free Mixed Berry Pie.

Pie Recipes to Fill Your Holiday Table

Classic Holiday Pies

1. Apple Pie

Homemade apple pie with flaky lard crust, cinnamon-scented apples, and golden-brown top crust.

Best for: a traditional Thanksgiving dessert
Makes: 1 (9-inch) double-crust pie

James Beard Award-winning cookbook author Cheryl Alters Jamison has spent decades chasing the apple pie of her childhood. Her secret is a crust made with lard, butter, and shortening. It’s flaky and slightly savory, and it wraps a mix of tart and sweet apples spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg.

2. Dutch Apple Pie with a Twist

A slice of Dutch Apple Pie sits on a white plate. Dutch Apple Pie recipe

Best for: crumb-topping fans
Makes: 1 (9-inch) pie

Amy Price’s family recipe folds tart apples into a tangy sour cream custard, adds a hint of fresh ginger, and finishes the pie with a brown sugar and cinnamon crumble and toasted pecans instead of a top crust.

3. Sweet Potato Pie

Sweet potato pie served in a metallic plate with three forks and a bowl of black eyed peas on the side

Best for: a crowd, or Kwanzaa
Makes: 2 (9-inch) deep-dish pies

Chef Jackie Page ends her Kwanzaa feast with this warmly spiced pie. Boiled sweet potatoes, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and a bright hit of lemon zest bake into a smooth, sliceable filling. The recipe makes two pies.

4. Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie

Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie: Decadent twist on a classic recipe, stealing the spotlight at every table.

Best for: a grown-up pecan pie
Makes: 1 (10-inch) deep tart

Pastry chef Selina Progar melts dark chocolate into a classic brown sugar and pecan filling. She spikes it with bourbon and bakes it in a buttery all-butter crust. Sweetened whipped cream balances the richness.

Fruit and Berry Pies

5. Raspberry Glaze Pie

Raspberry Glaze Pie on two different plates along with flowers in a glass of water and a sandwich in a small plate

Best for: a no-bake filling
Makes: 1 (8-inch) pie

This signature recipe comes from Sand Hill Berries, the family farm near Mount Pleasant. Whole raspberries are folded into a glossy raspberry glaze and spooned into a baked pie shell, so every berry stays intact.

6. Gingered Peach and Blackberry Pie

Gingered Peach and Blackberry Pie served in a glass plate with different-colored flowers in a glass on the side

Best for: a bakery-style custard pie
Makes: 1 (9-inch) pie

Roasted, caramelized peaches and fresh blackberries are baked in a creamy custard. Three kinds of ginger flavor the pie: ground, freshly grated, and crystallized. Frozen peaches make it a year-round dessert.

7. Cherry Blueberry Pie

A cherry blueberry pie with stars as a top crust, in a cobalt blue, scalloped edge pie dish sitting on a blue cotton towel on a rustic wooden surface with chipped light blue paint

Best for: a freezer-friendly fruit pie
Makes: 1 (9-inch) double-crust pie

Star Laliberte cooks frozen cherries and blueberries into two separate fillings and layers them, so every bite is a little surprise. Top the pie with a lattice, a full crust, or cutout stars.

8. Whole Grain, Gluten-Free Mixed Berry Pie

A homemade gluten-free blueberry pie surrounded by flowers. On the crust is a picture of a house.

Best for: gluten-free guests
Makes: 1 (11-inch) pie

Quelcy Kogel builds a flaky crust from rice, oat, and buckwheat flours and ground chia. She fills it with seven cups of berries sweetened with coconut sugar and honey, plus a little balsamic and black pepper.

Cream and Chocolate Pies

9. White Christmas Coconut Pie

A pie with a creamy white coconut filling and toasted coconut top.

Best for: a make-ahead Christmas dessert
Makes: 1 (9-inch) pie

This Gooderham family recipe is a light coconut chiffon pie. A gelatin custard is folded with whipped cream and meringue, then crowned with toasted coconut that looks like fresh snow.

10. The Richest Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

An aerial shot of a chocolate peanut butter pie decorated with whipped cream and Reese's with a slice cut out on a plate beside a fork.

Best for: a no-bake showstopper
Makes: 1 (9-inch) pie

Kylie Thomas spreads a dense peanut butter and cream cheese filling into a graham cracker crust. A layer of chocolate ganache goes on top, and Reese’s cups finish it, so it tastes like a giant peanut butter cup.

11. Chocolate Mint Pie

An aerial view of Chocolate Mint Pie with a side of whipped mint cream. Chocolate Mint Pie Recipe

Best for: chocolate lovers
Makes: 1 (10-inch) deep-dish pie

Rhonda Schuldt fills a flaky crust with a silky, two-chocolate mousse and finishes it with clouds of mint whipped cream. It’s a cool, candy-cane-bright finish to a heavy holiday meal.

How Far Ahead Can You Make Thanksgiving Pies?

Most pies can be made a day or two ahead, which frees up the oven on the big day. Pie dough keeps in the refrigerator for two days or in the freezer for three months. Fruit pies, pecan pie, and sweet potato pie can be baked one to two days ahead. The chocolate mint, peanut butter, and coconut pies need several hours to set, so they’re best made the day before. Add whipped cream toppings just before serving.

Do Pies Need to be Refrigerated?

Pies made with eggs or dairy need to be refrigerated within two hours of baking or cooling. That includes the sweet potato, pecan, Dutch apple, peach custard, cream, and chocolate pies. Fruit pies such as apple, cherry blueberry, and mixed berry can sit loosely covered at room temperature for up to two days. The raspberry glaze pie should be refrigerated and eaten within 12 hours.

How Do You Keep Pie Crust From Getting Soggy?

Blind-bake or par bake crusts for custard and cream pies. That means baking the crust with pie weights before adding the filling. Bake fruit pies on a preheated baking sheet on the lowest rack so the bottom crust browns. Let fruit fillings cool before you spoon them in.

Tips for Success

Keep everything cold. Cold butter and ice water make the flakiest crust. If the dough softens while you work, chill it for 15 minutes.

Shield the edges. Cover the rim with foil or a pie shield once it’s golden.

Cool completely. Most pies need at least two to three hours to set before slicing.

What Can I Serve With Christmas Pies?

Vanilla ice cream, softly whipped cream, and a sharp cheddar for the apple pie are all classic partners. Pour coffee, a glass of tawny port, or a bourbon cocktail like our Ancho Chile Old Fashioned.

Want more holiday desserts? Bake a Spiced Cranberry Tart or a Winter White Pavlova, and browse Dessert Recipes to Fill the Thanksgiving Table and our Ultimate Guide to Christmas Cookie Recipes. 

Planning the rest of the meal? See our 50 Thanksgiving Side Recipes, and find more fall baking ideas in our Apple Recipes to Embrace the Fall Season.

About the Writer

Kylie Thomas (she/they) is TABLE Magazine’s online editor, covering restaurants, events, and Pittsburgh lifestyle, including the magazine’s Things to Do in Pittsburgh column. A summa cum laude graduate of Point Park University, she has written for The Takeout and QBurgh. Read more of her work at TABLE.

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.

Subscribe to TABLE's email newsletter

We respect your privacy.

Don't Miss

spot_img

Related Articles

Beef Wellington for Two with Crosshatched Potatoes and Maple Carrots

Chef Jackie Page wraps seared beef filets and mushroom duxelles in golden puff pastry, then rounds out the plate with crisp crosshatched potatoes and bourbon maple carrots.

Pollo in Umido, a Venetian Braised Chicken with Rosemary Potatoes

Slow-braised in white wine, herbs, and tomatoes, this traditional chicken from Italy’s Veneto is simple, deeply comforting, and even better the next day.

Herb-Crusted Rack of Lamb with Traditional English Mint Sauce

A garlic-Dijon coat and a minty breadcrumb crust make this rack of lamb a showstopping holiday main, served with a sweet-sharp English mint sauce you can make days ahead.