Black and Gold Recipes for Steelers Game Day with Local Beer Pairings

Black and gold runs deep in this city. In April 2026, Pittsburgh hosted the NFL Draft and welcomed a record 805,000 fans over three days. Now the Steelers are back on the field, and the party has moved to living rooms, tailgates, and watch parties that deserve a menu worthy of the colors.

- Advertisement -

For this spread, Chef Kevin Hermann of 408 Heirloom, his restaurant on East Ohio Street on the North Side, built six recipes around ingredients from local farms. There are smoked short ribs, chicken tostadas, pulled pork, grilled shrimp, and two desserts in the team’s colors. Neil Glausier, co-owner and brewmaster at Millvale’s Burghers Brewing, paired each dish with one of his beers. Most of the work happens the day before, so you can watch the game instead of the oven.

Which Steelers Game Day Recipes Fit Your Party?

Black Pepper Crusted Short Ribs: a low-and-slow smoker showpiece

- Advertisement -

Blackened Cajun Chicken Tostada: a make-ahead handheld for a crowd

BBQ Pork Sandwich: pulled pork with blackstrap molasses BBQ sauce

- Advertisement -

Char-Grilled Shrimp Skewers: a lighter plate with blue corn grits

Golden Berry Tart: a bright, custardy dessert in gold

Black Forest Cake: a chocolate and cherry finale in black

Black and Gold Recipes for Steelers Fans

Black Pepper Crusted Short Ribs

Two plates with Black Pepper Crusted Short Ribs, a corn hash, and grilled peppers in yellow and green.

Best for: a smoker showpiece
Serves: 6 servings
Beer pairing: Roots & Resilience Black IPA

Bone-in short ribs get a crust of cracked black pepper and coriander and smoke for about four hours. Chef Hermann serves them over roasted corn hash with a pickled golden pepper salad. Look for grass-fed beef from Pittsburgher Highland Farm.

Blackened Cajun Chicken Tostada

Small Blackened Cajun Chicken Tostadas sit on a black rectangular tray on top of a wood table.

Best for: a make-ahead party bite
Serves: 6 servings (18 tostadas)
Beer pairing: Zelibrator Doppelbock

Grilled Cajun chicken, black bean salsa, chipotle aioli, and queso fresco pile onto crisp corn tortillas. Every component can be made ahead. Chef Hermann starts with pasture-raised chicken from Footprints Farm.

BBQ Pork Sandwich

Three BBQ pork sandwiches with pickles on top of the meet and a beer in the top right corner.

Best for: an all-day smoke with little hands-on work
Serves: 8 sandwiches
Beer pairing: Smoke Control Rauch Helles

Pork shoulder smokes for eight to 10 hours, then piles onto toasted brioche with grainy mustard, pickles, and homemade blackstrap molasses BBQ sauce. The pork comes from Fallen Aspen Farm in Lawrence County.

Char Grilled Shrimp Skewers

A yellow plate of char grilled shrimp skewers with blue corn grits and golden beet salad under it and slices of charred limes on the sides.

Best for: a lighter plate
Serves: 6 servings
Beer pairing: Cholo Mexicano Amber Lager

Spiced shrimp hit a hot grill for a few minutes, then land on creamy blue corn grits with golden beet relish and charred limes. The golden beets come from Shenot Farms.

Golden Berry Tart

A circle pan holds a vanilla custard tart with sliced gold berries all along one side.

Best for: a bright, make-ahead dessert
Serves: 8 servings
Beer pairing: Farkleberry Tart, a blueberry pomegranate Berliner weisse

Golden berries, also called Cape gooseberries, taste of mango, pineapple, and strawberry. Here they top vanilla custard in an almond pastry shell with dark chocolate shavings. Find the berries at the East End Food Co-op.

Black Forest Cake

A Black Forest Cake in a pan with white frosting and brandied cherries on top.

Best for: a showstopping finale
Serves: 12 servings
Beer pairing: Oat Black Water

Dark chocolate layers get a honey cream cheese crème, a ground chocolate coating, and brandied cherries. Start it the day before. Chef Hermann recommends cream cheese from Penn State’s Berkey Creamery.

What Beer Goes Best With Game Day Food?

Glausier’s pairings follow a few rules you can use with any menu. Match intensity, so rich, smoky dishes get beers with enough body to stand up to them. Echo a flavor, as the beechwood-smoked rauch helles does with the pulled pork. Then add contrast: crisp, citrusy lagers cool down spice, and tart, fruity beers keep desserts from feeling heavy. For a mixed crowd, set out one light lager, one dark beer, and one fruit-forward option. Learn more in Glausier’s lesson in enjoying beer.

How Do I Plan a Steelers Party Menu Ahead?

The day before, bake the cake layers and tart shell, whip the crème, cook the custard, and make the BBQ sauce, pickled peppers, salsa, aioli, beet relish, and grits. Rub the pork and short ribs and refrigerate them overnight.

On game day, start the pork early. For a 1 p.m. kickoff, it goes on the smoker before dawn, or smoke it a day ahead and reheat it. Put the short ribs on about four and a half hours before you eat. Assemble the desserts in the morning, then grill the chicken and shrimp as guests arrive.

Can I Make These Recipes Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, or Nut-Free?

The short ribs, tostadas, and shrimp contain no gluten. For the rest:

  • Gluten-free: Use gluten-free buns and a 1:1 gluten-free baking flour for the tart and cake.
  • Dairy-free: Use olive oil in the corn hash and grits, skip the queso fresco, choose a dairy-free bun, and use plant-based butter, milk, and cream cheese in the desserts.
  • Nut-free: Only the tart contains nuts. Replace the almond flour with an equal weight of all-purpose flour.

Tips for Success

Cook to temperature. Short ribs are tender at 200 to 205 degrees inside, pork shoulder at 195 to 203, and chicken is done at 165.

Hold hot food in a cooler. Smoked meat wrapped in foil and towels stays hot in an empty cooler for up to two hours.

Keep cold food cold. Don’t leave custard, aioli, or crème out for more than two hours.

What Can I Serve With These Black and Gold Recipes?

Chef Hermann’s sides mix and match. The corn hash and pepper salad from the short ribs are just as good with the pulled pork, and the beet relish brightens the ribs. Add coleslaw and chips, and pour an Apple Cider Manhattan made with Dubliner Steelers Select for anyone skipping beer.

Looking for more game day inspiration? Browse our Steelers game day recipes and Chef Hermann’s tips for successful summer grilling, or see more of his cooking in The Last Warm Evening, including his Apple Pudding Cake. Stir up a Hot Honey Old Fashioned, and find more bites in our Appetizers collection.

About the Recipe Developer and Stylist

Chef Kevin Hermann is the chef behind 408 Heirloom on East Ohio Street on Pittsburgh’s North Side. A graduate of the Culinary Institute of America at Hyde Park, he has cooked at restaurants and clubs across the country. In Pittsburgh, he helped develop Eat’n Park’s Six Penn Kitchen and Hello Bistro and was executive chef at The Porch at Schenley. Known for seasonal, local cooking that gives comfort food a fresh spin, he shares his tips for successful summer grilling and cooked TABLE’s The Last Warm Evening dinner.

About the Beer Pairing Expert

Neil Glausier is co-owner and brewmaster of Burghers Brewing, which brews in a 14,000-square-foot production brewery and restaurant in Millvale. He has led beer pairing classes for TABLE; read his lesson in enjoying beer.

About the Photographer

Dave Bryce is TABLE Magazine’s principal photographer. Known for images that explore depth and dimension through space and light, he is also a commercial and editorial food photographer who works closely with chefs and food stylists. Meet TABLE’s contributors.

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition.

Subscribe to TABLE's email newsletter

We respect your privacy.

Don't Miss

spot_img

Related Articles

Beef Wellington for Two with Crosshatched Potatoes and Maple Carrots

Chef Jackie Page wraps seared beef filets and mushroom duxelles in golden puff pastry, then rounds out the plate with crisp crosshatched potatoes and bourbon maple carrots.

Pollo in Umido, a Venetian Braised Chicken with Rosemary Potatoes

Slow-braised in white wine, herbs, and tomatoes, this traditional chicken from Italy’s Veneto is simple, deeply comforting, and even better the next day.

Herb-Crusted Rack of Lamb with Traditional English Mint Sauce

A garlic-Dijon coat and a minty breadcrumb crust make this rack of lamb a showstopping holiday main, served with a sweet-sharp English mint sauce you can make days ahead.